100% FREE

Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield

MyStreetCheck free street report: Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield · 31 October 2026 · www.mystreetcheck.co.uk/sheffield-south-yorkshire/castle-garden-street/

House prices, sold prices and local information for S36 8BE, S36 8BD.

Average price (last 12 months)
£262,500
1 sale
Average price (since 2023)
£279,704
25 sales
Price range
£56k – £378k
lowest to highest sale
Last sale
26 Jun 2026
S36 8BE

Free, no sign-up. Other sites charge up to £25.

At a glance

House prices£280k averageSince 2023 (few recent sales) CrimeLower than averageLower crime than about 70% of neighbourhoods in England DeprivationLess deprived than mostDecile 9 of 10 (10 = least deprived) Flood riskNear a flood alert areaLower risk than a warning area Nearest station15 min walkPenistone station Schools2 rated Good or betterWithin 1.5 miles Ultrafast broadband100% of homesNational average 80% Freehold or leasehold96% freeholdAcross 74 Land Registry sales Conservation areaChecking…Planning designations Green beltChecking…Planning designations Listed buildingsChecking…Within about 200 m Planning applicationsChecking…Within 500 m, last 90 days

25 property sales on Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield have been recorded by HM Land Registry since 2023. In the last 12 months 1 home sold here for an average of £262,500. Most sales here are detached homes, which have sold for an average of £330,583. 4 homes here have sold more than once since 2023; 0 of them sold for more the second time. By property type, sales here have been 52% detached, 32% terraced, 16% semi-detached. Recorded sale prices on Castle Garden Street range from £56,237 to £378,145. 96% of homes sold here were freehold and 4% leasehold.

House prices on Castle Garden Street compared

S36 postcode area£249,196
Sheffield£258,622
England & Wales£358,701

Average sale price over the last 12 months. Castle Garden Street has had fewer than two sales in that time, so it is left out. See all S36 house prices.

Average sale price by year

2023: £282,495 (2 sales)2023£282k2024: £295,763 (14 sales)2024£296k2025: £253,054 (8 sales)2025£253k2026: £262,500 (1 sales)2026£263k

Tenure: 96% freehold and 4% leasehold across 74 recorded sales.

Prices by property type

TypeSalesAverage priceLast sold
Detached13£330,58327 Jun 2025
Terraced8£200,02028 Mar 2025
Semi-detached4£273,71626 Jun 2026

Sold prices on Castle Garden Street

AddressDatePriceTypeTenure
26, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 26 Jun 2026£262,500 Semi-detachedLeasehold
28, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 7 Aug 2025£266,887 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
41, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 27 Jun 2025£344,495 Detached New buildFreehold
56, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 28 Mar 2025£263,995 Terraced New buildFreehold
62, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 26 Mar 2025£56,237 TerracedLeasehold
82, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 28 Feb 2025£219,995 Terraced New buildFreehold
30, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 21 Feb 2025£168,834 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
32, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 21 Feb 2025£168,834 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
80, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 21 Feb 2025£213,746 Terraced New buildFreehold
55, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 7 Feb 2025£305,168 Detached New buildFreehold
58, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 24 Jan 2025£274,596 Terraced New buildFreehold
23, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 10 Jan 2025£374,995 Detached New buildFreehold
59, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 10 Jan 2025£276,371 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
57, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 20 Dec 2024£310,337 Detached New buildFreehold
38, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 13 Dec 2024£275,995 Detached New buildFreehold
61, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 13 Dec 2024£289,995 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
84, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 13 Dec 2024£227,996 Terraced New buildFreehold
34, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 11 Dec 2024£143,864 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
36, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 11 Dec 2024£143,864 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
43, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 11 Dec 2024£153,212 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
45, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 11 Dec 2024£153,212 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
47, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 11 Dec 2024£153,212 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
49, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 11 Dec 2024£153,212 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
51, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 11 Dec 2024£169,334 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
53, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 11 Dec 2024£169,334 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
39, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 5 Dec 2024£378,145 Detached New buildFreehold
37, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 29 Nov 2024£336,995 Detached New buildFreehold
26, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 15 Nov 2024£263,397 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
35, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 7 Nov 2024£339,995 Detached New buildFreehold
19, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 1 Nov 2024£263,119 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
33, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 1 Nov 2024£266,918 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
31, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 31 Oct 2024£266,905 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
70, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 31 Oct 2024£168,941 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
72, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 31 Oct 2024£168,941 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
74, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 31 Oct 2024£143,864 Terraced New buildFreehold
76, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 31 Oct 2024£143,864 Terraced New buildFreehold
78, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 31 Oct 2024£143,864 Terraced New buildFreehold
29, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 25 Oct 2024£371,995 Detached New buildFreehold
54, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 27 Sep 2024£273,596 Terraced New buildFreehold
66, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 27 Sep 2024£168,941 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
68, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 27 Sep 2024£168,941 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
27, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 13 Sep 2024£357,995 Detached New buildFreehold
25, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 23 Aug 2024£335,995 Detached New buildFreehold
44, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 19 Aug 2024£289,757 Detached New buildFreehold
46, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 28 Jun 2024£168,941 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
48, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 28 Jun 2024£168,941 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
50, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 28 Jun 2024£168,941 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
52, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 28 Jun 2024£168,941 Semi-detached New buildFreehold
60, Castle Garden Street S36 8BE 28 Jun 2024£143,578 Terraced New buildFreehold
62, Castle Garden Street S36 8BD 28 Jun 2024£143,578 Terraced New buildFreehold
12

Sale prices are as recorded by HM Land Registry. Some sales (for example repossessions and company purchases) are listed but left out of the averages.

Sale history: homes sold more than once

AddressSalesChange
26, Castle Garden Street £263,397 (Nov 2024) → £262,500 (Jun 2026) +-0%
over 2 yrs
62, Castle Garden Street £143,578 (Jun 2024) → £56,237 (Mar 2025) -61%
over under a year
5, Castle Garden Street £163,185 (Dec 2023) → £69,998 (Jun 2024) -57%
over under a year
3, Castle Garden Street £19,107,000 (Jul 2021) → £284,995 (Aug 2023) -99%
over 2 yrs

Buying on Castle Garden Street?

Stamp duty calculator

Mortgage calculator

Crime and flood risk near Castle Garden Street

Crime

46 crimes were reported within about a mile of Castle Garden Street in August 2026.

Crime level compared with the rest of England (10 = lowest crime):

12345678910

Lower crime than about 70% of neighbourhoods in England, based on recorded crime rates (English Indices of Deprivation 2025).

Violence & sexual offences14
Anti-social behaviour10
Shoplifting10
Criminal damage & arson6
Other theft2
Public order2

Source: data.police.uk. Locations are approximate and cover the surrounding area, not just this street.

Flood risk

Castle Garden Street is in or near 2 Environment Agency flood areas:

  • Upper River Don catchment Flood alert area
  • River Dearne catchment Flood alert area

Flood warning areas cover places at risk from rivers and the sea. Surface water risk isn't included. Check the long-term flood risk for a postcode on GOV.UK.

Schools near Castle Garden Street

SchoolTypeAgesOfstedDistance
Penistone Grammar School 1,946 pupils Secondary 11–18 Report 0.4 mi
Penistone St John's Voluntary Aided Primary School 493 pupils Primary Church of England 3–11 Good Report 0.9 mi
Hoylandswaine Primary School 94 pupils Primary 4–11 Inadequate Report 1.0 mi
Thurlstone Primary School 182 pupils Primary 4–11 Good Report 1.0 mi
Springvale Primary School 227 pupils Primary 3–11 Report 1.1 mi
Oxspring Primary School 135 pupils Primary 4–11 Report 1.7 mi
Millhouse Primary School 100 pupils Primary 4–11 Good Report 2.0 mi
Denby Church of England Voluntary Aided First School 52 pupils Primary Church of England 4–10 Report 2.1 mi

Source: Department for Education (Get Information about Schools) and Ofsted. Grades are from each school's last graded inspection; newer inspections use report cards without a single overall grade, so check the full report. Distances are straight-line. Check catchment areas with the local council.

Getting around, shops and health

Train stations

  • Penistone station 0.8 mi · 15 min walk
  • Silkstone Common station 2.7 mi · 54 min walk
  • Denby Dale station 2.9 mi · 58 min walk

Nearest bus stops

  • Wellhouse Lane/Halifax Road (opp, Wellhouse Lane) 2 min walk
  • Well House Lane/Well House Way (adj, Well House Lane) 3 min walk
  • Barnsley Road/Wellhouse Lane (nr, Barnsley Road) 6 min walk
  • Barnsley Road/Wellhouse Lane (adj, Barnsley Road) 6 min walk

GP surgeries

  • Kingswell Surgery Pms Practice
    40 Shrewsbury Road, Penistone, Sheffield · 0.7 mi
  • Penistone Group Pms Practice
    19 High Street, Penistone, Sheffield · 0.9 mi

Supermarkets

  • Tesco Tesco Penistone Superstore · 0.7 mi
  • The Co-operative Food Co-op Penistone · 0.8 mi
  • Spar Spar - Penistone · 0.8 mi
  • Asda Express Asda Silkestone Express Petrol · 2.7 mi

Pharmacies

  • Clark's Chemist · 0.7 mi
  • Penistone Pharmacy · 0.7 mi

Dentists

  • Dental Surgery · 0.9 mi

Sources: Department for Transport (NaPTAN), NHS England organisation data, and GEOLYTIX Retail Points (open data). Walking times are estimates from straight-line distance.

Area profile

Deprivation

12345678910

This neighbourhood is in decile 9 of 10 on the English Indices of Deprivation 2025, where 1 is the most deprived 10% of areas in England and 10 the least deprived.

Income10 of 10
Employment10 of 10
Education and skills10 of 10
Health and disability8 of 10
Crime8 of 10
Access to housing and services3 of 10
Living environment8 of 10

Each domain ranked in deciles across England (10 = least deprived).

Homes

HereEng & Wales
Owned88.7%62.5%
Private rented8.0%20.3%
Social rented3.3%17.1%
Households764

People

HereEng & Wales
Under 1516.2%17.4%
Aged 15–6457.9%64.1%
Aged 65+25.9%18.6%
Residents1,842

Broadband

HereUK
Superfast (30Mbit+)100%95%
Ultrafast (300Mbit+)100%80%
Gigabit-capable100%80%

Share of homes on this street's postcodes that can get each speed. UK figure is the average across all postcodes. Source: Ofcom Connected Nations.

Mobile signal

HereEng & Wales
4G indoors, all 4 networks89%89%
4G indoors, at least 1 network100%100%
4G outdoors, all 4 networks100%99%
Calls indoors, all 4 networks92%92%

Share of homes across Barnsley with good coverage (Jul 2025). Signal varies street by street; check your exact address on Ofcom's checker. Source: Ofcom Connected Nations.

Neighbourhood figures cover the surrounding Lower Layer Super Output Area (about 1,500 residents). Sources: Census 2021 (ONS) and the English Indices of Deprivation 2025.

Energy ratings and home sizes on Castle Garden Street

Loading energy certificates…

Who lives around Castle Garden Street

Ethnic group

HereBarnsley
White97.3%96.9%
Asian, Asian British or Asian Welsh1.3%0.9%
Mixed or Multiple ethnic groups0.8%0.9%
Black, Black British, Black Welsh, Caribbean or African0.4%0.7%
Other ethnic group0.2%0.5%

Religion

HereBarnsley
Christian59.6%51.3%
No religion33.8%42.1%
Not answered5%5.2%
Muslim0.5%0.6%
Other religion0.5%0.4%
Sikh0.3%0.1%
Hindu0.2%0.2%
Buddhist0.1%0.2%

Country of birth

HereBarnsley
Born in the UK97.3%93.6%
Born outside the UK2.7%6.4%

Highest qualification

HereBarnsley
Level 4 qualifications and above45.1%23.5%
Level 3 qualifications14.8%16.9%
Level 2 qualifications12.7%14.5%
No qualifications11.3%25.1%
Level 1 and entry level qualifications8%10.8%
Apprenticeship6%6.6%
Other qualifications2.1%2.6%

General health

HereBarnsley
Very good health55.1%43.4%
Good health31.2%33.6%
Fair health10.7%15.5%
Bad health2.3%5.8%
Very bad health0.7%1.7%

Cars or vans per household

HereBarnsley
2 cars or vans in household46.9%27.4%
1 car or van in household31.3%41.5%
3 or more cars or vans in household16.8%8.4%
No cars or vans in household5.1%22.7%

Source: Census 2021 (ONS), via Nomis. Percentages of usual residents or households, as recorded in March 2021.

Figures cover the surrounding neighbourhood (Lower Layer Super Output Area, about 1,500 residents). Full demographics of Barnsley.

Planning and heritage near Castle Garden Street

Checking conservation areas, listed buildings and other designations…

Noise, radon and ground hazards

Checking…

Planning applications near Castle Garden Street

Recent planning applications around Castle Garden Street from the council's planning register. Choose how far to look:

Checking recent planning applications…

Thinking of selling on Castle Garden Street?

Get a free valuation

Local estate agents will value your home for free, with no obligation.

What's my home worth?

Get an instant estimate from what you paid and how prices in Barnsley have moved since.

Estimate my home's value

Council tax here

Barnsley Band D is £2,326 a year (Band A £1,551). See every band.

Estate agents near Castle Garden Street

Agent locations © OpenStreetMap contributors. More local agents

What's it like living on Castle Garden Street?

No reviews yet. Live here, or used to? Be the first to say what it's like.

Write a review of Castle Garden Street

Reviews are checked before they appear. Please don't name individuals or include personal details.

Nearby streets in S36

See all streets in Sheffield All streets in S36

You might also like

Most expensive streets in SheffieldWhere the priciest homes in Sheffield sellCheapest streets in SheffieldThe most affordable streets in SheffieldHouse prices in BarnsleyHow much prices have risenCouncil tax in BarnsleyEvery band for this yearWhat's my house worth?A free estimate from what you paidMoving costs calculatorStamp duty, fees and removals in one totalRent vs buy in BarnsleyIs buying cheaper than renting here?Where can I afford?Other streets at this price